For insurers, this is not just a market size story. It is a structural challenge.

EVs now account for a growing share of the broader car insurance ecosystem, reflecting how quickly underwriting assumptions are shifting. That shift represents a fundamental change in the kind of risk being underwritten. The pricing models most insurers use today were built around internal combustion engine vehicles- standard workshop costs, well-understood failure patterns, and a dense network of repair shops that created price competition.

EVs fit none of those assumptions. They carry sophisticated battery systems, onboard software, and high-voltage components that most garages are not equipped to handle. The service network has not kept up. Most EV repairs still flow through manufacturer-authorised centres, which are limited in number and unevenly distributed. Technicians trained for high-voltage systems remain hard to find, particularly outside major cities.

The Hidden Cost Challenge: Why Repair Inflation is Reshaping Claims Economics

Even outside the EV question, conventional motor insurance in India is under pressure. Spare parts prices have climbed consistently. Labour costs at authorised service centres have risen. The cost of settling claims has gone up, and MoRTH and IRDAI have been in discussions to raise third-party motor premiums by up to 10%, driven in part by mounting insurer losses, especially from commercial vehicle segments.

For EVs, the repair economics are still more extreme.

EV batteries account for 40 to 50% of the vehicle’s total value, with replacements costing anywhere from ₹3 lakh to ₹6 lakh or more. A small accident can lead to a ₹7 lakh claim on a ₹15 lakh car, not because the damage is severe, but because insurers often cannot safely repair a damaged battery casing and must replace the entire pack. Battery replacements for premium EVs can easily cost ₹8 lakh to ₹15 lakh, frequently exceeding the total value of a five-year-old conventional vehicle.

This creates a claims dynamic that conventional actuarial models were not built to handle. The frequency of total-loss declarations rises. The average claim size increases. And premiums, in response, go higher, even for owners who never file a claim.

EVs Are Introducing a New Layer of Risk Assessment

Beyond repair costs, EVs carry risks that simply did not exist under conventional motor insurance frameworks.

• One such risk is thermal runaway. An EV battery fire behaves differently from an engine fire. It is harder to extinguish, can reignite hours after appearing dormant, and often causes far greater structural damage. Standard fire coverage clauses were not written with this in mind, and many existing policies have gaps around it.
• Flood risk is another. India’s monsoon seasons routinely cause waterlogging across urban roads, and EV batteries, positioned low in the chassis, are directly exposed to that risk. Standard motor policies were not written with this failure mode in mind, and coverage gaps around flood-related battery damage remain unresolved across most products.
• Indian cities frequently experience waterlogging during monsoon seasons, presenting a risk that is both widespread and difficult to price accurately for EVs. Liability during charging is another emerging grey area. If a fire starts during home charging and spreads to property, the boundary between motor and home insurance becomes contested.

How Technology is Helping Insurers Adapt

Telematics- the use of GPS and sensor data to monitor driving behaviour, is gaining traction in India. The Indian insurance telematics market is growing at a CAGR of 21.4% through 2033, driven by demand for usage-based insurance, better fraud prevention, and behaviour-linked pricing. Under usage-based models, premiums are calculated based on how a vehicle is actually driven- distance covered, braking patterns, time of day, speed.

EVs also generate large volumes of operational data, enabling better risk profiling. Fleet operators integrating telematics at scale create a more stable risk environment – one where preventive maintenance, driver discipline, and predictive data combine to reduce claim frequency.

AI is changing how claims are handled on the ground. When an accident happens, AI-powered tools can assess damage from photos, estimate repair costs, and move the claim forward faster than a manual review ever could. It also helps insurers spot patterns that suggest fraud- inflated bills, staged accidents, repeat claimants, before payouts are made. Some products now go a step further, using mobile-based crash detection to alert the insurer the moment a collision happens and dispatch roadside help automatically, with nothing extra installed in the car.

OEM partnerships are another emerging avenue. When insurers work directly with EV manufacturers, they gain access to vehicle-level data that makes risk assessment far more precise. The insurer knows battery health. They know whether the vehicle has been in an unreported minor collision. They can price accordingly, and settle claims with far less ambiguity.

Implications for Vehicle Owners and Insurers

For both vehicle owners and insurers, EV adoption introduces new considerations around coverage, pricing, and risk exposure. While a comprehensive car insurance policy offers broad protection against accidents, theft, and natural calamities, EV ownership introduces new considerations around how risks are covered and priced. This shift has also led to the emergence of more specialised electric car insurance products that are better suited to EV-specific risks like battery damage, charging issues, and higher repair costs.

Standard comprehensive policies often do not cover battery degradation or damage from flooding without specific add-ons. In 2025, IRDAI introduced new premium models and coverage guidelines tailored to EV risks, and insurers have developed add-ons like battery protection that are critical for EV owners.

EV insurance premiums in India are typically 20 to 25% higher than equivalent petrol or diesel vehicles. Factoring this into total cost of ownership calculations at the point of purchase, rather than discovering it afterward, helps owners make genuinely informed decisions.

Cashless claim network coverage is another variable worth checking. The garage network for EVs is far smaller than for ICE vehicles. Limited service networks also introduce logistical challenges, particularly outside major cities.

The Future of Motor Insurance: From Protection to Risk Intelligence

India’s motor insurance sector is in the middle of a structural shift. The industry will not look the same in 2030 as it does today, and the transition is already underway.

Over time, cost pressures are expected to ease as the ecosystem matures. Battery prices have been falling for years and are expected to keep declining, which matters because the battery is currently the main reason EV claims cost so much. As that changes, premiums will follow. The repair network will expand, trained technicians will become more common, and parts will be easier to source. The friction that makes EV insurance expensive today is largely a growing pain, not a permanent feature.

Insurance pricing will change too. Right now, premiums are largely fixed- calculated once a year based on the vehicle’s age and size. That model will give way to something more flexible, where what you pay reflects how you actually drive, how healthy your battery is, and how much you use the vehicle.

Final Thoughts

India’s mobility landscape is changing at a pace that few would have predicted five years ago. The insurance sector has the tools, the regulatory framework, and the commercial incentive to keep pace. The key question is whether insurers can proactively adapt their models or remain reactive to change.

For vehicle owners, the message is straightforward: understand your coverage, know what your policy excludes, and treat insurance as an active financial decision, not an annual checkbox.

The pages slugged ‘Brand Connect’ are equivalent to advertisements and are not written and produced by Forbes India journalists.