| Average Yearly Costs | Compared to National Average | |
| Florida | $3,682 | + $2,199 |
| Louisiana | $3,310 | + $1,827 |
| New York | $2,526 | + $1,043 |
| National | $1,483 | N/A |
| Idaho | $1,338 | – $145 |
| Iowa | $1,218 | – $265 |
| Maine | $1,035 | – $448 |
Source: Liberty Mutual analysis of data from The Zebra
High Costs Compel Some Drivers to Seek Short-Term Savings
Drivers are often aware of these fluctuations and the associated financial effects.
“I moved from one of the least expensive states for total cost of car insurance to Florida, which is the most expensive state in the nation for insurance premiums and one of the lowest for teachers’ salaries,” said a high school science teacher who spoke on condition of anonymity.
“I knew I wouldn’t be able to afford insurance in Florida, so I kept my car registered in the other state and hoped that I’d never get into an accident or be found out by my insurance company. But I just can’t afford the high cost of car insurance in Florida on my annual salary below $45,000.” —Florida high school teacher who spoke on condition of anonymity
There may be short-term financial pressure to keep an out-of-state registration to maintain affordable insurance, especially for people living on tight salaries or in areas with generally high living costs.
“When I first moved to California, I was surprised by the high auto insurance rates. It felt like a penalty just for changing ZIP codes,” said Brad Scharf, the chief operating officer of Go Auto Insurance, who splits his time between California, Illinois, and Louisiana. “I had a clean driving record, but my premium nearly doubled overnight, so I delayed registering my vehicle in the new state.”
Scharf kept his vehicle registered in Illinois for six months longer than the legal limit for registering in California before eventually registering in the Golden State. Scharf said his decision to delay wasn’t an intentional desire to skirt the rules, but rather a need for time to adjust to the higher auto insurance costs he hadn’t been expecting when relocating.
Registering a Car Elsewhere Carries Serious Risks
Paying lower auto insurance premiums by registering your car elsewhere may seem enticing, but it risks voiding your insurance altogether.
Insurance companies base your rates on where your car will be principally garaged. They frequently determine this by where the vehicle is parked overnight. Registering your car elsewhere is considered misrepresentation, a type of insurance fraud that can automatically negate your coverage and even lead to criminal charges.
“In states like Florida or California, insurance rates can be brutal. But from a legal standpoint, the risk can never match the savings.” —Adam Dayan, personal injury attorney in Chicago
“If you’re living in a new state and still registered somewhere else, you’re violating both vehicle registration laws and insurance terms,” said Dayan.
An insurance company can refuse to pay claims if a vehicle’s actual principally garaged location does not align with the location stated on the car’s registration.
“If you’re in an accident and the insurer finds out your information was false, they could deny the claim altogether,” said William K. Holland, a law expert and managing partner of Holland Injury Law, LLC in St. Louis, Missouri. “You’d be personally responsible for medical bills, property damage, and legal fees, which could easily run into tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars.”
Warning
If you’re pulled over by law enforcement, an officer can take possession of a vehicle that has fraudulent insurance. In some situations, criminal charges for insurance fraud involving misrepresentation can be filed.
Understand Your State’s Laws
Knowing how to avoid misrepresenting where your vehicle is principally garaged is the best way to steer clear of the risks associated with the practice. When changing your primary residence, make sure that you know how long your new state allows drivers to legally register their vehicles. Researching the time frame allotted for registering vehicles in an area can prevent you from inadvertently misrepresenting your situation.
Each state has unique laws for how long you have to register a vehicle when moving to that state, as well as specific laws for the type of insurance and minimum coverage you must carry.
Most states give new residents between 30 and 60 days to register, but Florida gives new residents only 10 days after they start working there.
Tip
When in doubt, ask an insurance agent where your car should be registered to guarantee accurate insurance coverage.
Other Ways to Save on Car Insurance
Avoiding costly long-term repercussions can save you on car insurance, but that’s not your only recourse. There are many legally acceptable routes to lower auto insurance premiums, including:
- Bundling auto insurance with other forms of insurance, such as home insurance. To do this, consult with a local insurance agent
- Maintaining a clean, safe driving record
- Comparison shopping for insurance in your area
- Asking an insurance agent for discounts, including multi-car, teen, and good student discounts
Based in New York, Stephen Freeman is a Senior Editor at Trending Insurance News. Previously he has worked for Forbes and The Huffington Post. Steven is a graduate of Risk Management at the University of New York.