Last year my Saga over-50s car insurance policy cost £1,155, so you can imagine the shock when the renewal came through for this year and it was £2,044 – nearly double the price of last year.

I phoned customer service to find out why it had gone up so much, and was advised that “prices have gone up”. I was given no other information.

My understanding is that the cost of my premium is based on risk, and the likelihood of me making a claim.

But nothing has changed. I am a female IT consultant in my 50s who has been driving for 20 years. My no-claims bonus is for 10 years, and I have never had an accident (touch wood).

So if Saga has fairly calculated my premium by assessing my risk, then, to my mind, it should have gone down, not up.

I think Saga, along with many other companies, is simply taking advantage of the current financial crisis to increase its profit margins.I love my car but would rather sell it than pay this rip-off renewal price.
MB, by email

The 77% increase quoted is out of kilter with a market where prices are up. The average price paid for motor insurance in the first three months of 2023 was £478, which is 16% higher than in 2022, according to the Association of British Insurers (ABI) motor insurance premium tracker.

The trade body says higher bills reflected the “above-inflation cost pressures” facing motor insurers, and pointed to a 30% increase in secondhand car prices and a 16% increase for paint and material costs. Still … 77%!

Saga says: “We are experiencing high levels of claims inflation which, in turn, has meant that premium and renewal prices have unfortunately had to rise, too.

“Material shortages have caused spare parts, such as microchips and semiconductors, to become more expensive because of demand.

“Not only that, but they also take longer to arrive, which extends the time cars are out of action after a claim, and then extends the time (and increases the cost) claimants need a courtesy car for.”

It adds: “Saga is fully supportive of, and compliant with, the market reforms introduced by the Financial Conduct Authority last year. This means that our existing customers pay no more than new customers at renewal.”

You drive a four-year-old Audi TT and have secured a new policy for £979 from a competitor. Not only is this cheaper than last year’s deal with Saga, it is a cool £1,065 cheaper than this year’s quote.

So shop around, folks …

We welcome letters but cannot answer individually. Email us at consumer.champions@theguardian.com or write to Consumer Champions, Money, the Guardian, 90 York Way, London N1 9GU. Please include a daytime phone number. Submission and publication of all letters is subject to our terms and conditions